Category Archives: Juries

Issues peculiar to trial by jury.

Dangerous Driving Conviction Precludes Driver from Contesting Liability in Civil Action

The decision of Mr. Justice David M. Brown in Caci v. MacArthur raises some interesting questions relating to apportionment of fault. It also applied to this MVA action a line of decisions in sexual abuse cases, where defendants had not been … Continue reading

Posted in Evidence, Juries, Practice and Procedure, Trial Procedure | Comments Off on Dangerous Driving Conviction Precludes Driver from Contesting Liability in Civil Action

Montebello Post-Mortem

     Another successful Civil Litigation Update concluded at Chateau Montebello yesterday. The conference, now in its 26th year, was acclaimed by numerous visiting Superior Court and Court of Appeal judges as Ontario’s premiere continuing legal education program. We are proud … Continue reading

Posted in Auto, Costs, Insurance News, Juries, Threshold | Comments Off on Montebello Post-Mortem

Judge Finds that Threshold Motion Must Succeed Where Jury Assesses Damages at Zero

Bisier v. Thorimbert was an action for personal injuries arising out of a motor vehicle accident. At the trial, Mr. Justice J.R. Henderson of the Ontario Superior Court granted the defendant’s motion for dismissal of the plaintiffs’ claim, on the basis that … Continue reading

Posted in Auto, Auto (Tort), Insurance News, Juries, Threshold, Trial Procedure | Comments Off on Judge Finds that Threshold Motion Must Succeed Where Jury Assesses Damages at Zero

Defence Counsel’s Opening Address Leads to Discharge of Jury

In Morrison et al. v. Greig et al., Mr. Justice Bruce Glass of the Ontario Superior Court discharged the jury following the opening address of counsel for the defendant. In this trial of two personal injury actions, arising out a … Continue reading

Posted in Juries, Trial Procedure | Comments Off on Defence Counsel’s Opening Address Leads to Discharge of Jury